[
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-001",
    "plain_name": "Dasein and situated dasein stay distinct",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I]",
    "proposition": "Capitalized Dasein names the selected coherent whole while situated dasein names a finite actual bearer within it; neither is an inventory of the other.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Ordinary whole-part and standpoint language does the same work with fewer commitments.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill the vocabulary if it repeatedly reifies the whole or erases finite bearers.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "Whether Dasein is the best ontology remains open.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:MET:ONE_MANY"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-002",
    "plain_name": "Finity is determinate manifestation",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I]",
    "proposition": "Finity names determinate manifestation in a declared frame, not finite cardinality and not numeric one.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "14_THE_DISTILLATION/00_THE_AMRITA.md",
        "sha256": "dce26b620dfa9b30eee9880c85c6204f1aa3dc3ce6b281ae50ce55109067e97f", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Standard terms such as defined value, limit, event, or instantiation are clearer.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Retire Finity wherever it adds ambiguity rather than a valid type distinction.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "No new arithmetic follows from the name.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "FORMAL:FIELD-01"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-003",
    "plain_name": "Value, word, process, operator, and boundary are different types",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "A value, its written sign, a generating process, an operator, and a boundary object may be related without being identical.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "14_THE_DISTILLATION/00_THE_AMRITA.md",
        "sha256": "dce26b620dfa9b30eee9880c85c6204f1aa3dc3ce6b281ae50ce55109067e97f", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Native mathematical type systems already prevent these collisions.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill any claimed novelty or extra result not earned beyond the native type discipline.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "The native distinctions survive without Emergentist names.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:LOG:REFERENCE"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-004",
    "plain_name": "Higher descriptions may add explanatory value without blocking reduction",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I/C]",
    "proposition": "A macro description can remain explanatorily useful when a lower-level reduction exists, provided it earns prediction, intervention, compression, or portability after costs.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Matched lower-level models may equal or beat every macro benefit.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Demote to mnemonic wherever matched native models equal or beat it on held-out value and cost.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "Reduction and native domain models remain.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:SCI:EMERGENCE"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-005",
    "plain_name": "Quantum state and actual record are different types",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I]",
    "proposition": "A probability-bearing quantum state and a definite measurement record should not be conflated, even though the distinction alone does not solve measurement.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Standard quantum foundations already separates states, channels, apparatus and records.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill distinctiveness if the typing adds no correct prediction or clarification beyond native accounts.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "The measurement problem and Born-rule interpretation remain open.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:SCI:MEASUREMENT"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-006",
    "plain_name": "Commitment and received consequence need separate receipts",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "An actor's stated plan or self-report is not the independently received consequence of the act.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Ordinary audit and causal-inference practice already enforces this separation.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill the framework-specific claim if independent provenance adds no discipline beyond native audit practice.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "Independent outcome evidence remains necessary.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:SCI:CAUSATION"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-007",
    "plain_name": "Possibility acts only through actual carriers",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Represented D5 possibilities influence action only through actual D4 models, bodies, utterances, instruments, memories or institutions.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Standard representational and control theories explain the same causal chain.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill the framework-specific gloss if it adds no discriminator beyond present-carrier models.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "Possible content remains distinct from physical causation.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:MIN:INTENTIONALITY"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-008",
    "plain_name": "The Soul Loop preserves execution and outcome gaps",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I]",
    "proposition": "A useful reflective loop keeps perception, modelling, commitment, authorization, execution, observation and revision distinguishable.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Decision journals and feedback control provide a simpler equivalent.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Retire Soul Loop vocabulary if it adds no error detection, correction or transfer benefit.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "The underlying feedback and audit distinctions survive.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:EPI:EXTERNAL_WORLD"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-009",
    "plain_name": "Egregoreotype is an observable coordination hypothesis",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[C]",
    "proposition": "An egregoreotype may be tested as persistent distributed coordination with shared trace, incentive coupling, boundary maintenance and intervention-sensitive added value, without asserting personhood.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Carrier identity, incentives, direct communication and environment may exhaust the effect.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill the construct if those native variables exhaust prediction and intervention response.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "The observable carriers and coordination mechanisms remain.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:POL:COLLECTIVE_ACTION"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-010",
    "plain_name": "Language may deepen coordination",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[C]",
    "proposition": "Shared language may add coordination depth beyond thin exchange signals, but it transfers no truth, consent or common worldview by itself.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Repeated interaction, incentives and institutions may explain all coordination gains.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill the incremental claim if language variables add no held-out predictive or intervention value.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "Trade and communication remain bounded coordination channels.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:LOG:RULE_FOLLOWING"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-011",
    "plain_name": "Worldview competition can be one cause of conflict",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[C]",
    "proposition": "Conflicting coordination patterns may contribute to war alongside security, capacity, geography, finance, trauma and revenge.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Material and strategic variables may exhaust the explanatory gain.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill the worldview variable if it adds no held-out value after native conflict controls.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "The multicausal conflict account and nonviolence fence survive.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:POL:POWER"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-012",
    "plain_name": "Rosetta axes must not collapse",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I]",
    "proposition": "Trophic role, replicator layer, reasoning function, operator alias and mating or kinship structure are separate axes unless a specific bridge is earned.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_META/00_ONE_SITTING_CLAIM_CARD_SET_01.md",
        "sha256": "5561c22d78be84040e15e25b420bfe201edf49cb251ba5c2fad9b331a3fca536", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "No crosswalk is needed; native taxonomies should remain separate.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill any crosswalk that predicts nothing and invites hierarchy or identity transfer.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "The native taxonomies remain authoritative.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:EPI:TESTIMONY"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-013",
    "plain_name": "Functions are trainable and mobile",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I]",
    "proposition": "Rosetta work functions are movable practices and never hereditary classes, ranks of human worth or sovereign identities.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_META/00_ONE_SITTING_CLAIM_CARD_SET_01.md",
        "sha256": "5561c22d78be84040e15e25b420bfe201edf49cb251ba5c2fad9b331a3fca536", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Plain role descriptions avoid caste and mythic hazards entirely.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Drop the aliases if they cause persistent rank, essence or authority leakage.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "Equal worth and trainable functional roles remain.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:POL:LEGITIMACY"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-014",
    "plain_name": "Operational agency is usable under metaphysical nonclosure",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I/C]",
    "proposition": "Agents can be assessed by represented options, means, authorization, action and correction while consciousness, ultimate freedom and post-death survival remain open.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Compatibilist and control-based agency already provide the usable account.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill distinctiveness if the decomposition changes no attribution, intervention or correction decision.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "The hard problem and ultimate freedom remain open.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:MIN:FREE_WILL",
      "PQA54@0.1:MIN:CONSCIOUSNESS"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-015",
    "plain_name": "Teleology needs two clocks and all bearers",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I/C]",
    "proposition": "A teleological proposal must expose short-horizon enactment and long-horizon option effects for every affected bearer rather than hiding delayed cost in one score.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Standard multi-criteria and intergenerational decision theory may dominate the framework.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill the transfer if it hides delayed cost, harmed bearers, uncertainty or decorative Exit.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "Bearer and horizon visibility remain useful.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "actors",
        "affected bearers",
        "future readers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:ETH:POPULATION"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-016",
    "plain_name": "Reciprocal public reason has a conditional bridge",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S/I/C]",
    "proposition": "Inside a voluntarily undertaken reciprocal public-reason practice, arbitrary denial of visibility, contest, correction or feasible Exit defeats the declared reciprocity.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Contractualism, discourse ethics or constructivism may explain the same duties more faithfully.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill or narrow the bridge if the conclusion is smuggled into reciprocity or adds no value over serious rivals.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "The practice premise and general is-ought problem remain explicit.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "actors",
        "affected bearers",
        "future readers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:ETH:IS_OUGHT"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-017",
    "plain_name": "Guardianship is separate from reciprocity",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I/C]",
    "proposition": "Care for dependent, absent, nonhuman, ecological and future bearers is a separately chosen, bounded and reviewable extension, not proof borrowed from co-agency.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Rights, capabilities, fiduciary, precautionary and supported-decision safeguards may perform better.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill or narrow the extension if it self-authorizes, hides conflicts or launders proxy harm.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "Dependent bearers still require visible protection against capture.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "actors",
        "affected bearers",
        "future readers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:POL:REPRESENTATION"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-018",
    "plain_name": "Moral objectivity must be typed",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S/I/C]",
    "proposition": "Definition stability, procedural reproducibility, empirical adequacy and stance-independent moral realism are different claims and must not inherit one another's warrant.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Established metaethical distinctions already perform the same separation.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill framework distinctiveness if it adds no clarity or hard-case discrimination.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "Moral realism remains open.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "actors",
        "affected bearers",
        "future readers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:ETH:MORAL_REALISM"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-019",
    "plain_name": "Selected is not solved",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[D/C]",
    "proposition": "A philosophical question earns a result only after native recovery, premise preservation, serious controls, unfired kills and independent native-domain review.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "03_METHODOLOGY/03_PREREGISTRATIONS/pqa_54/prompts/questions.json",
        "sha256": "1ea31b71c52c274960af9361994d77f0b849eee2579610822c25293a99280250", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Native peer review without a framework benchmark may be more faithful and efficient.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill the construct if it rewards reframing, hides residuals or adds no value over native and generic controls.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "The public denominator and correction ledger survive.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "SYNTH:PQA-EARNED-RESULT"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-020",
    "plain_name": "The means is the message",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[D]",
    "proposition": "How an act is carried already shapes the relation it claims to serve; carriers, costs, consent, authority, reversibility and externalities are part of the claim.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_HANDOFF/EMERGENTISM_ORG_V2_3_THIRD_CHURNING_OWNER_DIRECTION_2026_08_23.md",
        "sha256": "8fe987447d48a0dd9c559f7769bf05c7f42fd63f9edc0e26440608c744baf107", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "POST_FREEZE_OWNER_DIRECTION"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "Consequentialist cases may permit harmful means when expected outcomes dominate.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Reject the maxim as universal law if bearer-indexed hard cases show that its constitutive reading obscures justified exceptions.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "Means must still be disclosed and contested.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "actors",
        "affected bearers",
        "future readers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "SYNTH:MEANS-MESSAGE"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-021",
    "plain_name": "The ends are the limits",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[D]",
    "proposition": "Every desired end remains bounded for each affected bearer and responsible horizon; no aggregate end erases a failed row.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_HANDOFF/EMERGENTISM_ORG_V2_3_THIRD_CHURNING_OWNER_DIRECTION_2026_08_23.md",
        "sha256": "8fe987447d48a0dd9c559f7769bf05c7f42fd63f9edc0e26440608c744baf107", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "POST_FREEZE_OWNER_DIRECTION"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "A defended aggregation rule may justify trade-offs across bearers and horizons.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Reject the non-aggregation reading where a transparent authorized scalar robustly handles hard cases better.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "Hard limits, uncertainty and Exit remain visible.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "actors",
        "affected bearers",
        "future readers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "SYNTH:ENDS-LIMITS"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-AMR-022",
    "plain_name": "G7 closure is vocabulary-scoped",
    "mythic_alias": "AMRITA",
    "classification": "SURVIVOR_CANDIDATE",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Four bearer-oriented transfers plus three read-only frames close the selected G7 vocabulary and nothing larger.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The vocabulary is an arbitrary mnemonic with no explanatory benefit.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Kill its use if it obscures native game structure or repeatedly collapses necessary distinctions.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The native problem, source record and explicit residual remain.",
    "residual_debt": "The four typed transfer cells and three separate frame labels remain removable.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [
      "PQA54@0.1:SCI:EMERGENCE"
    ],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-001",
    "plain_name": "Titan glyphs are not arithmetic operands",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Treating •, ⊙ or ○ as ordinary numeric operands or sovereign arithmetic identities is a type error unless a separate numeric model is explicitly declared.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "14_THE_DISTILLATION/04_WHAT_DIED.md",
        "sha256": "2753cfc380135cc842bff68ca865ee70a38cdd772486dc7b1e9484802c458d84", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-002",
    "plain_name": "Dasein is not a self-containing set or jointly actual world bundle",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I]",
    "proposition": "Do not turn the selected Dasein whole into a naive self-membered set, make rival possible worlds jointly actual, or identify one ego with the whole.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-003",
    "plain_name": "Convergence is not proof",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Cross-tradition resemblance, model agreement and repeated rendering are robustness clues, never independent truth evidence by themselves.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "14_THE_DISTILLATION/00_THE_AMRITA.md",
        "sha256": "dce26b620dfa9b30eee9880c85c6204f1aa3dc3ce6b281ae50ce55109067e97f", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-004",
    "plain_name": "Finity is not finite cardinality or numeric one",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Do not reduce Finity to finite cardinality or identify the centre glyph with ordinary numeric one.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "14_THE_DISTILLATION/00_THE_AMRITA.md",
        "sha256": "dce26b620dfa9b30eee9880c85c6204f1aa3dc3ce6b281ae50ce55109067e97f", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-005",
    "plain_name": "Generative arithmetic does not replace field mathematics",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "No Titan or projective notation makes field division by zero defined or replaces native mathematics without an explicit structure change.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "05_COSMOLOGY/03_FORMAL_SYSTEM/48_FINITY_PARADOX_LEDGER.yaml",
        "sha256": "07c2d9a114624ec4720a66602e8ddf7a47142f1996cec588c025778656d410f6", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-006",
    "plain_name": "A process is not its completed denotation",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "A non-halting or asymptotic process may denote a completed object in a declared semantics but is not identical to that denoted value.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "05_COSMOLOGY/03_FORMAL_SYSTEM/48_FINITY_PARADOX_LEDGER.yaml",
        "sha256": "07c2d9a114624ec4720a66602e8ddf7a47142f1996cec588c025778656d410f6", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-007",
    "plain_name": "Missing reduction is not proof of strong emergence",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Failure to provide a reduction is explanatory debt, not evidence that ontological strong emergence has been proved.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-008",
    "plain_name": "Macro novelty needs matched controls",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "A higher-level description earns no novelty claim without fair lower-level, native and complexity-matched controls.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-009",
    "plain_name": "Quantum state, record and time must not collapse",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Do not equate quantum state with event, infer temporal order from unordered snapshots, or claim that D3 typing solves measurement.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "05_COSMOLOGY/03_FORMAL_SYSTEM/48_FINITY_PARADOX_LEDGER.yaml",
        "sha256": "07c2d9a114624ec4720a66602e8ddf7a47142f1996cec588c025778656d410f6", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-010",
    "plain_name": "Self-issued success is not world-contact evidence",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "An actor's own success report can record commitment but cannot alone establish received consequence or independent calibration.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-011",
    "plain_name": "Possibility itself does not physically act",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "D5 possible content does not push matter, widen a light cone or cause events without an actual D4 carrier or separately evidenced law.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "05_COSMOLOGY/02_EMERGENTISM_CORE/F5Fork.v1.json",
        "sha256": "09b2c5700a20fd2d90ad0c2dc11999ad048faea0baf6ce08ac327809a9c1ddb6", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-012",
    "plain_name": "Present future models do not prove retrocausality",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Ordinary model-mediated anticipation is not evidence for a future-boundary interaction or F5-R.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "05_COSMOLOGY/02_EMERGENTISM_CORE/F5Fork.v1.json",
        "sha256": "09b2c5700a20fd2d90ad0c2dc11999ad048faea0baf6ce08ac327809a9c1ddb6", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-013",
    "plain_name": "Aliases are not castes, essences or verdicts",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Mythic names and Titan frames must not become hereditary human classes, person-worth ranks or pre-outcome moral judgments.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_META/00_ONE_SITTING_CLAIM_CARD_SET_01.md",
        "sha256": "5561c22d78be84040e15e25b420bfe201edf49cb251ba5c2fad9b331a3fca536", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-014",
    "plain_name": "Four plus three does not prove seven is necessary",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "G7 closes only the selected vocabulary and does not prove exactly seven fundamental kinds or exhaust all games.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-015",
    "plain_name": "The Burrisphere itinerary is not time or moral ascent",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "The selected 360-degree reading path is not recurrence, chronology, physical helix, causal mechanism or moral rank.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-016",
    "plain_name": "M4 is not a global or vector-space basis",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "M4 may be tested as a lossy code only inside a frozen comparator class; it is not a reconstruction theorem or globally unique basis.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-017",
    "plain_name": "The centre is not universally optimal or costless",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "The reciprocal centre is analytically balanced but not a universal empirical optimum, trade-off eraser or Dharma theorem.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-018",
    "plain_name": "Egregoreotype does not confer personhood",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Persistent coordination does not by itself establish consciousness, legal personhood, autonomous authority or moral patienthood.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-019",
    "plain_name": "Synchrony and trade do not establish truth or consent",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Coordination signals can support inference but do not establish truth, fairness, consent or a shared worldview by themselves.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-020",
    "plain_name": "War is not reducible to worldview competition",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[I]",
    "proposition": "Worldview conflict is at most one variable among material and strategic causes and never licenses violence.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-021",
    "plain_name": "Rosetta axes do not form hereditary hierarchy",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Trophic, replicator, reasoning, operator, Varna and mating axes may not be collapsed into a hereditary rank order.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_META/00_ONE_SITTING_CLAIM_CARD_SET_01.md",
        "sha256": "5561c22d78be84040e15e25b420bfe201edf49cb251ba5c2fad9b331a3fca536", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-022",
    "plain_name": "Aggregates do not hide harmed bearers",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Sacrifice language, product scores and total option gains cannot cancel an undisclosed harmed bearer.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "actors",
        "affected bearers",
        "future readers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-023",
    "plain_name": "Consciousness, free will, death and afterlife remain open",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Operational decompositions do not solve the hard problem, ultimate freedom, death or personal survival.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "11_UPLINK/50_AUDITS_AND_EXECUTIONS/188_THE_PARADOX_INVENTORY_2026_07_30.md",
        "sha256": "7fd27952d85a39ed46d909f500a96f9f368b98236cb464f6f8970b61f99f9707", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-024",
    "plain_name": "Geometry does not prove morality or cosmic purpose",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "The reciprocal chart, RCAB and GEX do not prove stance-independent morality, cosmic teleology or coercive guardianship.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "actors",
        "affected bearers",
        "future readers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-025",
    "plain_name": "Force maps and strong emergence remain conjectures",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Correspondence, dimensional order and intuitive fit do not establish a force assignment or strong-emergence crossing.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-026",
    "plain_name": "D6 is not D0, afterlife, rank or sixth freedom",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "D6 is a nonclosure and Exit marker; boundary-role resemblance neither identifies it with D0 nor makes it an attainment or afterlife.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_THE_WELTANSCHAUUNG_ONE_SITTING.md",
        "sha256": "925a71453163d0a23e44c84cf023249014f71dfa99f45969d7a2bdd8d31c9bb0", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07",
        "claim_ids": [
          "OS01"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-027",
    "plain_name": "Selection, clarification and reframing are not resolution",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "A selected question or elegant reframe cannot be counted as dissolved or resolved, and a bounded majority cannot become most philosophy.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "03_METHODOLOGY/03_PREREGISTRATIONS/pqa_54/prompts/questions.json",
        "sha256": "1ea31b71c52c274960af9361994d77f0b849eee2579610822c25293a99280250", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-028",
    "plain_name": "Process receipts are not external validation",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[S]",
    "proposition": "Offline-ready, ratification, adherents, commits and AI agreement are bounded process facts rather than scientific or philosophical validation.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "14_THE_DISTILLATION/05_THE_METHOD.md",
        "sha256": "14c3b11399c931226129b4c186beb4c80da4f38e8b5bdddcbdf61cff576d78da", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "8b07e00c563f338923b1928d3469c862d44c1e07"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "readers",
        "researchers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "schema_id": "emergentism/ChurningDrop.v1",
    "drop_id": "TC-HAL-029",
    "plain_name": "The maxim is not a theorem or permission",
    "mythic_alias": "HALAHALA",
    "classification": "POISON_WARNING",
    "lifecycle": "SOURCE_BOUND",
    "evidence_tier": "[D]",
    "proposition": "The means-message and ends-limits maxim is a disclosed normative selection, never a theorem and never permission for ends to justify means.",
    "scope": "Third Churning frozen-source proposition",
    "assumptions": [
      "source and evidence tier remain attached",
      "publication does not create earned review"
    ],
    "source_refs": [
      {
        "path": "00_HANDOFF/EMERGENTISM_ORG_V2_3_THIRD_CHURNING_OWNER_DIRECTION_2026_08_23.md",
        "sha256": "8fe987447d48a0dd9c559f7769bf05c7f42fd63f9edc0e26440608c744baf107", "_sha256_scan": "# pragma: allow-secret",
        "frozen_commit": "POST_FREEZE_OWNER_DIRECTION"
      }
    ],
    "strongest_rival": "The warning may be overbroad; a narrowly typed model could lawfully recover part of the rejected claim.",
    "discriminator": "Compare the exact proposition with its native account and simplest serious rival on clarification, prediction, intervention, compression or harm detection.",
    "kill_criterion": "Narrow or retire the warning if an explicit typed model survives native review and its declared discriminator.",
    "cheapest_next_test": "One blinded native-domain review against a generic decomposition control.",
    "survivor_if_killed": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "residual_debt": "The narrow lawful use and native domain remain available.",
    "means_message": {
      "bearers": [
        "actors",
        "affected bearers",
        "future readers"
      ],
      "short_horizon": "publication and first application",
      "long_horizon": "revision after downstream consequence",
      "carrier": "source-bound text and machine record",
      "cost": "attention, implementation cost and risk of misclassification",
      "consent_or_mandate": "no worldview adoption required; consequence-bearing use needs a declared mandate",
      "authority": "source owners retain semantics; the projection cannot authorize action",
      "reversibility": "classification is revisable and predecessor bytes are preserved",
      "externalities": "overclaim, hidden bearer harm and model-training misquotation remain possible"
    },
    "ends_limits": {
      "target": "a clearer, contestable proposition and test",
      "hard_limit": "no tier promotion, false closure, hidden bearer or authority transfer",
      "option_change": "preserve challenge, correction and Exit",
      "residue": "unpaid explanatory and empirical debt stays visible",
      "exit": "drop the claim or framework when it adds no value",
      "uncertainty": "independent review and world contact remain absent"
    },
    "linked_problem_ids": [],
    "earned_review": {
      "state": "UNREVIEWED",
      "independent_review_count": 0,
      "receipts": []
    },
    "revision_history": [
      {
        "date": "2026-08-23",
        "event": "source-bound candidate created in the Third Churning rebuild"
      }
    ]
  }
]