{ "schema": "emergentism/frontier-ledger/v0", "status": "STAGED [D] — rendering of the validation register, not a result", "source": "00_META/claim_status/CLAIM_STATUS.yaml", "source_sha256": "36077fbc943e4a7e4960873278c08542d0fd7152452d680a4d00e5e5acf63d6f", "k_star": 0, "attention_capture": false, "completeness_claim": false, "world_contact_accepted": 0, "score": "tier movement against stated kill criteria only; a kill counts; reach does not", "not": [ "a complete ontology", "a promise that the frontier will close", "a reach or spread metric", "world contact", "Amrita emerged" ], "counts": { "validated": 21, "open": 19, "investigations": 9, "typed_survivors": 1, "graves": 22, "total": 72 }, "claims": [ { "id": "FV-01", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "phi=cot(theta/2), nu=tan(theta/2) imply phi*nu=1", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-02", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "(phi-nu)^2>=0 implies phi+nu>=2", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-03", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "B=2/(phi+nu)=sin(theta)<=1", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-04", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "phi=nu=1 uniquely maximizes B and minimizes phi+nu", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-05", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "log phi + log nu = 0; B=sech(s); H=2cosh(s)>=2", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-06", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "1 is the self-dual positive point", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-07", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "inversion fixes +1 and -1 and swaps the orbit {0, infinity}", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-08", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "Z minus {0} is not additively closed since (+1)+(-1)=0", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-09", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "the real projective line has real dimension one", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-10", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "no map from X to its power set is surjective", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-11", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "the unrestricted Russell class is not a set", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-12", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "the AND-class boundary conditions do not select a unique member", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-13", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "a locally pure gauge has zero local curvature", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-14", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "Fourier duality and noncommuting observables give the uncertainty principle", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-15", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "S", "statement": "G7 = M4 disjoint-union F3 has exactly seven symbols by construction, never by nature", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-16", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "S", "statement": "substrate stock falls by at least epsilon per unit time and the substrate-supported component of extractor power falls with it", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-17", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "S", "statement": "higher-level constraints reweight lower-law-admissible trajectories and never manufacture forbidden ones", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-18", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "S", "statement": "with the budget premise, full evaluated foresight leaves zero means and the node score is zero; without it, no such consequence", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-19", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "for any two ordered triples of pairwise distinct points of the complex projective line, a unique Möbius transformation maps the first triple pointwise to the second; two corresponding distinct source/target points leave a non-trivial one-parameter stabilizer (scaling after normalization); this forces three normalization constraints only in that named projective problem", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-20", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "S", "statement": "the declared metric-gradient flow ds/dt=-2tanh(2s) has sinh(2s(t))=sinh(2s(0))e^(-4t) and converges to s=0; no physical F5 dynamics follows", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "FV-21", "bucket": "validated", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "finite reachability is exactly the positive rationals, so sqrt(2) is in the state space but not finitely reachable; zero and infinity are approached boundaries, not finite attainments", "raise": "Already formally valid inside the declared system. A raise would be a category error.", "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W0-CROWN", "bucket": "open", "status": "NOT-WELL-POSED", "tier": null, "statement": "optional creedal posture retained; no typed instantiation relation or modal/contact discriminator exists", "raise": null, "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W1", "bucket": "open", "status": "COMPONENT-SUPPORTED", "tier": null, "statement": "model-relative finite reachability is defined and witnessed; physical/domain discrimination remains open", "raise": "Freeze a real-domain state space, initial set, transformations, costs, bounds, and target before outcomes; derive at least one non-stipulated exclusion and a held-out consequence beyond relabelling what occurred.", "kill": "No target is excluded except by stipulation, or the typed bridge predicts nothing unavailable to occurrence-as-reachability redescription.", "survivor": "FV-21 and the model-relative admission-versus-reachability distinction survive without supporting plenitude or physical emergence.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W2", "bucket": "open", "status": "COMPONENT-SUPPORTED", "tier": null, "statement": "decoherence is real; the integrated reading does not inherit it", "raise": "Freeze state, dynamics, clock, instrument, context, horizon, and held-out record-order statistic; require an increment beyond the strongest matched native decoherence, histories, and timeless rivals.", "kill": "The result is decoherence redescription, imports an interpretation, or adds no held-out record-order discrimination.", "survivor": "Native quantum record science and D3/D4 bookkeeping survive; no definite-outcome, Born-rule, or ontic-plurality conclusion follows.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W3", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": null, "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W4", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "Validate independent commensurate cardinal scales, then compare the product with one-factor, additive, minimum, harmonic, and preregistered CES rivals on held-out evaluated work.", "kill": "The scale contract fails or a rival predicts as well on the frozen held-out outcomes.", "survivor": "Ordinal joint necessity and the selected minimum convention remain local scoring choices.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W5", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "Freeze a finite set of premise-satisfying systems and sample failures and disappearances as well as survivors; compare balance advantage against matched rivals.", "kill": "No balance advantage remains under survivorship-free sampling.", "survivor": "The four premises remain a scope statement, not an empirical law.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W6", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "Freeze domains, matched alternatives, full bearer accounting, and long-horizon durability and warranted-trust outcomes; prefer observational or natural experiments.", "kill": "The matched durability or warranted-trust increment fails across the preregistered set.", "survivor": "E8 remains a chosen vow rather than an empirical theorem.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W7a", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "Freeze a non-arbitrary D1-to-QCD map, recover an accepted QCD result, beat every row permutation, and predict a held-out QCD-specific quantity.", "kill": "The map is only opposites-bind language, permutes freely, or fails native-theory recovery.", "survivor": "QCD, D1, and founder provenance survive without the role-affinity claim.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W7b", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "Recover U(1) or Maxwell structure and a held-out electromagnetic-specific effect not inserted by hand, then beat every row permutation.", "kill": "Generic graph or geometry language fits every force, or the native observables are not recovered.", "survivor": "Electromagnetism and D2 configuration survive without the mapping.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W7c", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "Select chirality and flavor-changing weak structure rather than quantum transition generally, recover accepted electroweak theory, and predict a held-out weak observable.", "kill": "Strong or electromagnetic rows fit equally well, or no weak-specific increment exists.", "survivor": "Native weak theory and D3 survive without the mapping.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W7d", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "Recover general relativity and valid low-energy EFT without importing spacetime circularly, add a held-out boundary prediction, and beat row permutations.", "kill": "Native recovery fails, valid EFT is excluded, or the construction presupposes what it claims to map.", "survivor": "GR, low-energy EFT, and D4 actuality survive without the mapping.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W7e", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "After a nontrivial native dynamics is fixed, show a D5-specific intervention effect beyond control, learning, evolution, and teleonomy, and beat every force-row permutation.", "kill": "No independent dynamics, no incremental effect, free permutation, or retrocausality is required.", "survivor": "FV-20 and ordinary model-mediated anticipation survive without a fifth force.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W8", "bucket": "open", "status": "COMPONENT-SUPPORTED", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "First separate represented future content from salience, demand, reward, memory, and expectancy; then require an independent D5 measure to beat rich D4 planning, search, model-based, and model-free baselines.", "kill": "A fair-baseline null, unbounded all-timelines language, or dependence on physical coexistence of alternatives.", "survivor": "Ordinary causal anticipation through present model tokens remains.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W9", "bucket": "open", "status": "COMPONENT-SUPPORTED", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "Separately manipulate persistent trace, carrier turnover, incentives, command, and environment; require all five markers including recurrent bias and visible substrate costs.", "kill": "Any marker fails or carrier identity, incentives, direct coordination, or environment absorbs the effect.", "survivor": "Native trace-mediated coordination survives without consciousness, personhood, or composite attribution.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W10", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "Establish causal lineage separation before counting; freeze inclusion and centre-plus-mirror coding, use blind coders and negative controls, then test a held-out lineage against transmission and selection-bias rivals.", "kill": "Independence cannot be shown or recurrence does not beat the frozen null.", "survivor": "Inherited grammar within known lineages remains descriptive provenance.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W11", "bucket": "open", "status": "DECORATIVE", "tier": null, "statement": "the extra worldview claim does no work beyond ordinary algebra and mnemonic symbolism", "raise": null, "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W12", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": null, "raise": "Compare the D6 stop-and-return instruction with a strongest belief-neutral fallibilist or defusion control on false closure, revisability, leaveability, burden, distress, and optional first-person reports.", "kill": "No incremental discrimination, harmful pressure, compulsory mediation, or non-revisability.", "survivor": "E10 nonclosure and exit discipline survive; the D6 symbol may retire.", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W10-SPARK", "bucket": "open", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": null, "statement": "Raised as one [I] claim; splits into an [S] aim, a [C] mechanism and an untiered presupposition. Only the mechanism is open here. See 00_META/ADJUDICATION_SPARK_AND_COMPLETENESS_2026_08_13.md.", "raise": "Once /record/frontier is served and reachable, materially higher engagement with the falsification register than with equivalent prose.", "kill": "Surface served, reachable, and unengaged over a declared interval. The mechanism dies; the aim narrows to a publishing choice.", "survivor": "The [S] publishing aim may remain. The amrita presupposition stays unnamed as paid.", "owner": "00_META/ADJUDICATION_SPARK_AND_COMPLETENESS_2026_08_13.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": { "mover": "Yves R. Burri (chair), adjudicated in session", "date": "2026-08-13", "evidence": "00_META/ADJUDICATION_SPARK_AND_COMPLETENESS_2026_08_13.md" }, "last_move_note": null, "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "W0-COMPLETE", "bucket": "open", "status": "NOT-WELL-POSED", "tier": null, "statement": "Raised as [C]. Register equivocation on 'complete', not a conjecture. Sibling of W0-CROWN. Not a verdict that the creed is false.", "raise": null, "kill": null, "survivor": null, "owner": "00_META/ADJUDICATION_SPARK_AND_COMPLETENESS_2026_08_13.md", "last_move": { "mover": "Yves R. Burri (chair), adjudicated in session", "date": "2026-08-13", "evidence": "00_META/ADJUDICATION_SPARK_AND_COMPLETENESS_2026_08_13.md" }, "last_move_note": null, "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "RQ-01", "bucket": "investigations", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": "C", "statement": "Is there an instrument that can test the equator-transfer claim at all?", "raise": "a design with survivorship-free sampling over premise-satisfying systems", "kill": "no admissible instrument exists, in which case W5 is untestable and must say so", "survivor": "the four premises remain a clear scope statement", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": "DF-06" }, { "id": "RQ-02", "bucket": "investigations", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": "C", "statement": "Does any real system instantiate a relational eta near zero as a witness?", "raise": "preregistered search across candidate mutualisms with full bearer accounting", "kill": "no candidate survives a bearer-complete audit", "survivor": "the vow stands as an openly chosen constraint with zero empirical witnesses", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": "DF-07" }, { "id": "RQ-03", "bucket": "investigations", "status": "NARROWED", "tier": "C", "statement": "Is there any hypothesis set under which N=3 is forced?", "raise": "exhibit hypotheses plus a proof, or prove a general no-go", "kill": "neither a forcing result nor a no-go after honest search", "survivor": "N=3 remains selected outside the named projective normalization problem", "owner": "05_COSMOLOGY/03_FORMAL_SYSTEM/21_TRIADIC_STABILITY_CORRESPONDENCE.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": "DF-11" }, { "id": "RQ-04", "bucket": "investigations", "status": "NOT-WELL-POSED", "tier": "C", "statement": "Is there a non-trivial substrate-plurality claim that survives the martyr counterexample?", "raise": "first define substrate, comparison unit, persistence horizon, and outcome under a new claim ID; only then can a matched comparison be admissible", "kill": "the required types cannot be declared without changing the claim, so this row has no executable discriminator", "survivor": "the universal minimum stays retracted; the three-function and three-rail design pattern remains interpretive", "owner": "00_META/00_THE_CLAIM_STATUS_REGISTER.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": "DF-13" }, { "id": "RQ-05", "bucket": "investigations", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": "C", "statement": "Can lineage independence be established for any convergence datum?", "raise": "historical and philological demonstration of causal separation before any counting", "kill": "no separable lineage can be shown", "survivor": "convergence carries zero evidential weight until causal separation is established", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/04_THE_CONJECTURES.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": "DF-15" }, { "id": "RQ-06", "bucket": "investigations", "status": "OPEN-EMPIRICAL", "tier": "C", "statement": "Does the civilizational analogy yield a discriminator?", "raise": "one held-out prediction the analogy makes that rival social science does not Freeze historical coding and rival typologies, then require one held-out prediction or classification increment from the named Rosetta features that rival social science does not supply.", "kill": "no discriminator after an honest attempt No held-out increment survives blind coding, provenance review, and rival comparison.", "survivor": "nothing; retire the analogy as decoration The analogy may remain a labelled mnemonic only.", "owner": "08_FRAMEWORK_SUPPORT/03_EVIDENCE/ROSETTA_STONE/ROSETTA_CIVILISATIONAL.md 03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": "DF-17" }, { "id": "RQ-07", "bucket": "investigations", "status": "NARROWED", "tier": "C", "statement": "Under what declared dynamics does the squared deviation tend to zero?", "raise": "state a dynamics, derive the trajectory, then test it", "kill": "no dynamics makes the trajectory non-trivial", "survivor": "the selected chart flow and static inequality survive; physical F5 content remains untested", "owner": "01_TELEOLOGY/02_THE_DERIVATION/10A_PATH_D_COMPUTATION.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": "DF-19" }, { "id": "RQ-08", "bucket": "investigations", "status": "NARROWED", "tier": "C", "statement": "Does any numeric overlay predict something not already known?", "raise": "one held-out quantitative prediction from the overlay", "kill": "no such prediction", "survivor": "unnamed overlays are mnemonic at most; named W7 candidates retain their own kills", "owner": "01_TELEOLOGY/02_THE_DERIVATION/07_THE_FOUR_FORCES_ARE_THE_FOUR_LINES.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": "DF-20" }, { "id": "RQ-09", "bucket": "investigations", "status": "NARROWED", "tier": "C", "statement": "Can REACHABLE be defined non-circularly?", "raise": "a definition from declared initial conditions, allowed transformations, and finite or convergent resource bounds that excludes some target", "kill": "no non-circular definition is found", "survivor": "model-relative reachability is coherent; plenitude and physical emergence remain unsupported", "owner": "06_ONTOLOGY/02_THE_DEGREES_OF_FREEDOM_ONTOLOGY.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": "W1" }, { "id": "TR-01", "bucket": "typed_survivors", "status": "FORMALLY-VALID", "tier": "A", "statement": "In their declared structures, projective inversion exchanges the two projective endpoints, the selected positive numeric midpoint is self-reciprocal, and the open reciprocal chart satisfies phi times nu equals one. These are numeric/projective facts, not Titan equations or identities.", "raise": null, "kill": null, "survivor": "the type firewall and keel fence: analytic, world-empty, and without Titan proof transfer; DF-21 applies verbatim", "owner": "05_COSMOLOGY/01_THE_TRANSCENDENTAL_TRINITY/45_THE_TITAN_INVERSION_STRUCTURE.md", "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-01", "bucket": "graves", "status": "FORMALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "unification by derivation", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "four structural breaks recorded in `126_WELTANSCHAUUNG_FORMAL_AUDIT_2026_07_13.md` section 5", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "GP-11", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-02", "bucket": "graves", "status": "CATEGORY-ERROR", "tier": null, "statement": "ethic-as-theorem", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "is-to-ought bypass by redefinition", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "E8", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-03", "bucket": "graves", "status": "EMPIRICALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "seven-as-forced and Rosetta-as-universal", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "planetary confound; the cleanest witness carries the seven visible planets", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "W10", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-04", "bucket": "graves", "status": "FORMALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "product-uniqueness as keel", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "FV-12: minimum instantiates the same zero boundary", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "W3", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-05", "bucket": "graves", "status": "CATEGORY-ERROR", "tier": null, "statement": "phi*nu=1 as a conserved discovery", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "a coordinate identity read as a world law", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-06", "bucket": "graves", "status": "EMPIRICALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "the symmetric balance hump as empirical law", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "Munnell trough; the GFS study was retracted by its owner", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "RQ-01", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-07", "bucket": "graves", "status": "EMPIRICALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "the squid as an eta=0 witness", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "D. gigas is panmictic, semelparous, and weak-targeting", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "RQ-02", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-08", "bucket": "graves", "status": "FORMALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "literal D6 identical to D0", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "loop-as-equation fails: D6 and D0 are not identical, and no order, homeomorphism or physical recurrence relates them — only a boundary-role resemblance survives (`126_WELTANSCHAUUNG_FORMAL_AUDIT_2026_07_13.md` A3-5)", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "W12", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-09", "bucket": "graves", "status": "FORMALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "forced Titan-3", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "FV-07: inversion fixes two points, not one", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "W11", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-10", "bucket": "graves", "status": "FORMALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "force bijection", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "117_FORCE_LADDER_FORMALIZED_07B.md and 117_PATH_D_NEGATIVE_RESULT.md show that photon and gluon share the free-field threshold, gravity has a separate graviton threshold, the massive weak vector supplies no fourth force-specific threshold, and Path D yields 0, 1, or 2 rays rather than Standard Model gauge structure; electroweak unification is supporting context, not the no-go by itself", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "W7a", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-11", "bucket": "graves", "status": "FORMALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "N=3 forced", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "explicit Z5 counterexample; the group lemma is false", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "RQ-03", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-12", "bucket": "graves", "status": "FORMALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "Godel universal lift", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "Presburger arithmetic and real-closed fields are complete and decidable", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "E9", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-13", "bucket": "graves", "status": "NOT-WELL-POSED", "tier": null, "statement": "three substrates minimum", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "the signed universal minimum remains retracted; the martyr defeats a minimum of three organisms or independently embodied agents but is not by itself a proof about substrate cardinality, as corrected in 132_TOMBSTONES_HALAHALA_REAUDIT_2026_07_19.md", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "RQ-04", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-14", "bucket": "graves", "status": "FORMALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "universal frame/operand exclusivity for ordinary numbers", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "ordinary numeric identities are operands", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "KSC-04", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-15", "bucket": "graves", "status": "CATEGORY-ERROR", "tier": null, "statement": "convergence-as-proof", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "fifteen renderings of one shape are one datum, not fifteen confirmations", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "RQ-05", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-16", "bucket": "graves", "status": "FORMALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "extraction is irrational as a general Nash result", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "private side-payments break it outside Model A", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "W6", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-17", "bucket": "graves", "status": "NOT-WELL-POSED", "tier": null, "statement": "civilizational physics", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "a conjecture-tier analogy asserted as physics; no discriminator was ever stated", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "RQ-06", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-18", "bucket": "graves", "status": "NOT-WELL-POSED", "tier": null, "statement": "dissolves the Hard Problem, is-ought, death, and free will", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "unfalsifiable frame-trick; mechanism asserted rather than shown", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "HC-11", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-19", "bucket": "graves", "status": "FORMALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "ektropy and F5 as the teleological force", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "(phi-nu)^2 supplies no trajectory; a static inequality is not a dynamics", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "RQ-07", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-20", "bucket": "graves", "status": "CATEGORY-ERROR", "tier": null, "statement": "numeric coincidences as derivations", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "overlay is not derivation; the horn-torus and light-cone identification was killed by `151_HORN_TORUS_SR_FORMAL_AUDIT_2026_07_20.md`", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "RQ-08", "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-21", "bucket": "graves", "status": "FORMALLY-REFUTED", "tier": null, "statement": "CC-CORE-1, the kernel-to-ethics warrant", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "the seam holds precisely off the catastrophe case, so it was never evidence for the multiplicative floor", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": null, "parent": null }, { "id": "DF-22", "bucket": "graves", "status": "PROCESS-DEFECT", "tier": null, "statement": "Rosetta kill-criterion mislabel", "raise": "Forbidden. Graves do not thaw. A weaker successor needs its own ID.", "kill": "a fired falsifier was logged as a pass", "survivor": null, "owner": null, "last_move": null, "last_move_note": "CLAIM_STATUS.yaml does not record who moved this row or when. Unrecorded, not invented.", "successor": "E9", "parent": null } ] }