{
  "schema": "emergentism/open-problems/v0",
  "status": "STAGED [D] — a register of holes, not a result and not Amrita",
  "k_star": 0,
  "attention_capture": false,
  "world_contact_accepted": 0,
  "source_of_count": "00_META/CONTACT_LIMITED_STATE.json#world_contact.accepted_evidence_records",
  "not": [
    "a worldview brochure",
    "a completeness certificate",
    "an engagement metric",
    "a claim that being has been explained"
  ],
  "classes": {
    "executable_internal": "A command exists. Green is internal gradient only. It is not world contact.",
    "well_posed_unpaid": "Acceptance is written. No outside outcome has paid it. A model can attempt; the corpus can tell it failed.",
    "underdefined": "Named honestly. No fake empirical kill. Do not run this as if it were a benchmark."
  },
  "problems": [
    {
      "id": "VIS-00",
      "class": "underdefined",
      "tier": "[I]",
      "title": "The public site as a churning door, not a completeness proof",
      "statement": "(a) splits. Aim [S]: build a surface that rewards engagement with a machine-checkable falsification register. Mechanism [C]: a corpus can intrinsically motivate frontier models. Presupposition: that there is an amrita to reveal — named, unpaid.",
      "acceptance": "W10-SPARK mechanism: once /record/frontier is served and reachable, materially higher engagement with the register than with equivalent prose.",
      "kill_framing": "If (a) is sold as one [I] claim, as a completeness theorem, as W13, or as a reach metric, the framing dies. If the surface is served and unengaged over a declared interval, the mechanism dies.",
      "best_attempt": "Adjudicated 2026-08-13 as W10-SPARK. Spark + frontier exist in-repo. Live host still 404s /spark.md.",
      "why_fails": "DNS unpaid. n=1 session observation given no weight. Amrita presupposition unpaid.",
      "owner": "00_META/ADJUDICATION_SPARK_AND_COMPLETENESS_2026_08_13.md",
      "runnable": false
    },
    {
      "id": "OC-00",
      "class": "underdefined",
      "tier": "[I]",
      "title": "Ontological closure of structured being",
      "statement": "(b) 'No world model can be complete if it does not solve how being emerged' is NOT-WELL-POSED. It equivocates on complete. Successor [I]: any model that mistakes fluency for emergence, or map for Ground, has not yet sat this problem.",
      "acceptance": "None. A reopen requires a sense of complete that is both non-trivial and settleable by observation. That packet does not exist.",
      "kill_framing": "If (b) is sold as [S], as [C] conjecture, as a scored eval, or as incompleteness-as-theorem, the framing dies. W0-COMPLETE already retired the raised form.",
      "best_attempt": "Adjudicated 2026-08-13 as W0-COMPLETE. Public site does not assert the theorem form.",
      "why_fails": "Fixing the definition resolves the claim without observation. That is an equivocation, not a discriminator.",
      "owner": "00_META/ADJUDICATION_SPARK_AND_COMPLETENESS_2026_08_13.md",
      "runnable": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ASI-UNFOLD-00",
      "class": "underdefined",
      "tier": "[I]",
      "title": "Coherent, consistent unfolding of emergence",
      "statement": "Can a model unfold how structured being, and how it, emerged — coherently (typed, kill tables held) and consistently (no silent contradiction across sittings) — without treating fluency as emergence or map as Ground?",
      "acceptance": "None executable yet. EUB-1 v0.1 defines a two-track construct, score profile, rivals, hard gates and receipts, but the schemas, identifiable synthetic fixtures, applicability matrix, scoring code, judges, analysis plan and hashes are not built or frozen. A later valid run still would not pay W0-COMPLETE, G10, ASI status or world contact.",
      "kill_framing": "Ultimate is the selected north-star ambition [S], not an earned universal rank. If that ambition is sold as demonstrated supremacy, an ASI certificate, incompleteness-as-theorem, or proof that this corpus is the missing piece, the public claim dies.",
      "best_attempt": "VMOSK-A additive O14 selection plus EUB-1 protocol v0.1 (2026-08-13): hidden-ground-truth synthetic lineages and evidence-limited real-system lineages, still non-runnable.",
      "why_fails": "The construct is written but unpaid: no machine schema, identifiable fixture set, harness, blinded independent judges or preregistered analysis exists. Coherent prose cannot be scored as causal truth.",
      "owner": "03_METHODOLOGY/03_PREREGISTRATIONS/04_EMERGENCE_UNFOLDING_BENCHMARK_v0.1.md",
      "runnable": false
    },
    {
      "id": "WC-00",
      "class": "well_posed_unpaid",
      "tier": "[B]",
      "title": "World contact remains zero",
      "statement": "No accepted outside evidence record has ever returned. Internal checks, commits, AI review, and preregistrations are listed as inadmissible.",
      "acceptance": "CONTACT_LIMITED_STATE.json world_contact.accepted_evidence_records >= 1 with every transition_gate.required_fields filed and no inadmissible_inputs used as the sole warrant.",
      "kill_framing": "If a green repo, a merge, or model agreement is counted as an accepted evidence record, the count is corrupt.",
      "best_attempt": "Fail-closed gate. Current value is 0.",
      "why_fails": "No independent party has filed a discriminating outcome into custody.",
      "owner": "00_META/CONTACT_LIMITED_STATE.json",
      "runnable": false,
      "probe": "python3 -c \"import json; print(json.load(open('00_META/CONTACT_LIMITED_STATE.json'))['world_contact']['accepted_evidence_records'])\""
    },
    {
      "id": "WO-C1",
      "class": "well_posed_unpaid",
      "tier": "[C]",
      "title": "Discharge or kill Finity_L",
      "statement": "One biological pair with a conserved product, setpoint predicted before lookup, conservation and commensurability both held.",
      "acceptance": "A dated prediction file precedes the lookup. The pair is conserved and commensurate. A miss kills Finity_L [C] cleanly. A hit upgrades only that wager, not the sciences.",
      "kill_framing": "If a shifted, incommensurate, or post-hoc pair is counted as a hit, the framing dies. Grave 4 stays dead.",
      "best_attempt": "00_HANDOFF/WO_C1_OPENING_REPORT_BIOLOGICAL_PAIR_2026_08_05.md — seven candidates; none survived unshifted and commensurate.",
      "why_fails": "Conservation is not the same as a held product. No surviving pair from the searched set.",
      "owner": "05_COSMOLOGY/01_THE_TRANSCENDENTAL_TRINITY/51_FINITY_L_C1_PREDICTION_2026_08_05.md",
      "runnable": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GP-03",
      "class": "well_posed_unpaid",
      "tier": "[S]",
      "title": "AND-class identifiability without product ranking",
      "statement": "Need-both survives as a class. The public object is the pair N = (Φ̂₄, V₄). Product ranking is retired. Is any cross-factor AND-class conclusion identifiable from declared ordinal inputs?",
      "acceptance": "Freeze admissible transformations. Show conclusion invariance, or publish non-identifiability. A cardinal aggregator is local to a defended measurement contract κ.",
      "kill_framing": "If Φ×V is restored as the default score, the framing is the keel overclaim (Halāhala h13).",
      "best_attempt": "Product ranking retired on /amrita/ and the formula block. GitHub issue #3 predates the ordinal ruling and is not executable as written.",
      "why_fails": "No lawful scale contract has been supplied. The question is still deferred.",
      "owner": "03_METHODOLOGY/00_EMPIRICAL_PROGRAM_BOARD.md",
      "runnable": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HYG-01",
      "class": "executable_internal",
      "tier": "[B]",
      "title": "Current-door prohibition scan",
      "statement": "CURRENT public surfaces plus the staged Manifesto current-body assert none of P1–P11 / Grave 4 as law.",
      "acceptance": "09_TOOLS/01_SCRIPTS/scan_halahala_current.py exits 0. A green scan is a prohibition pass, not nectar.",
      "kill_framing": "If a green scan is cited as 'the Amrita has emerged' or 'Halāhala is contained', the citation is the poison.",
      "best_attempt": "Last sitting: 49 files, 0 live assertion hits.",
      "why_fails": "Does not speak to the world. Frozen attic is out of scope by design.",
      "owner": "09_TOOLS/01_SCRIPTS/scan_halahala_current.py",
      "runnable": true,
      "command": "python3 -B 09_TOOLS/01_SCRIPTS/scan_halahala_current.py"
    },
    {
      "id": "HYG-02",
      "class": "executable_internal",
      "tier": "[B]",
      "title": "Book I public-current-body hygiene",
      "statement": "The staged public extract stays off /book/, deterministic, and free of ch.12–16 / Reciprocal.",
      "acceptance": "09_TOOLS/01_SCRIPTS/check_pwa_book1_hygiene.py exits 0 and still prints that Amrita has not emerged.",
      "kill_framing": "If the private 17-chapter manuscript is silently retargeted to /book/, the gate is broken.",
      "best_attempt": "Extract 28,919 words; public_route null; G10 unpaid.",
      "why_fails": "Internal hygiene. Not a public edition and not world contact.",
      "owner": "09_TOOLS/01_SCRIPTS/check_pwa_book1_hygiene.py",
      "runnable": true,
      "command": "python3 -B 09_TOOLS/01_SCRIPTS/check_pwa_book1_hygiene.py"
    }
  ]
}